| Name | Year | Name | Year | Name | Year |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Joe Dotson | 1904-1905 | Bobby Bell | 1965 | James Hotopp Sr. | 2004 |
| G.W. Gray | 1906 | Frank C. Lindsey | 1966 | James Carlile | 2005 |
| Joe Dotson | 1907-1908 | James D. Garner | 1967 | Corry E. Lindsey | 2006 |
| W.T. Graves | 1909 | H.L. Lilley | 1968 | Ted Mastin | 2007 |
| J.N. Crisp | 1910 | E.L. Harwell | 1969 | Jerry Hudson | 2008 |
| Joe Dotson | 1911 | R.D. Russell | 1970 | James Jay | 2009 |
| W.M. Skiles | 1912 | Doyle Choate | 1971 | David B. Walters | 2010 |
| J.N. Crisp | 1913-1916 | Virgil McCoy | 1972 | Keith A. Lindsey | 2011 |
| W.M. Skiles | 1917-1919 | C.L Kegler | 1973 | R.H. Waters, PGM 1984 | 2012 |
| J.P. Rodgers | 1920-1921 | Ronnie R. Horn | 1974 | Rick Aldridge | 2013 |
| J.L Anderson | 1922 | Tommie Worrell | 1975 | Tracy Hudson | 2014 |
| W.H. Anderson | 1923-1924 | Corry E. Lindsey | 1976 | James Carlile | 2015 |
| W.M Skiles | 1925 | John D. Smith | 1977 | Johnny Hutchins | 2016 |
| W.C. Hickey | 1926 | Galen L. Lindsey | 1978 | Jerry Hudson | 2017 |
| O.J. Covey | 1927-1928 | J.R. “Bob” Russell | 1979 | James Hotopp Sr. | 2018 |
| John Anderson | 1929 | Gurley Hail | 1980 | Scott McCullers | 2019 |
| F.B. Shannon | 1930-1931 | Frank C. Lindsey | 1981 | James Johnson | 2020 |
| J.R. Skiles | 1932 | Tim Bivens | 1982 | Tracy Hudson | 2021 |
| Judson Hatler | 1933-1934 | Donald Parks | 1983 | Rob Walters | 2022 |
| D. O. Bordner | 1935 | David Anderson | 1984 | Matthew Hudson | 2023 |
| W.J. “Dink” Anderson | 1936-1937 | Jeffrey Siewert | 1985 | ||
| Oscar Parham | 1938 | Dallas Thompson | 1986 | ||
| W.C. “Pete” Parham | 1939 | Robert D. Hamilton | 1987 | ||
| A.R. Oxford | 1940 | John D. Smith | 1988 | ||
| G.E. Cosby | 1941 | O.L. Davis | 1989 | ||
| Guy Jackson | 1942 | Don Harding | 1990 | ||
| W.C. “Pete” Parham | 1943-1945 | Billy Porterfield | 1991 | ||
| J.R. Skiles | 1946-1949 | Scott McCullers | 1992 | ||
| W.J. “Dink” Anderson | 1950-1954 | James Adams | 1993 | ||
| Robert Worrell | 1955 | James Carlile | 1994 | ||
| Roy Underwood | 1956 | Jack Johnson | 1995 | ||
| Kenneth Trimble | 1957 | James Hotopp | 1996 | ||
| M.V. Worrell | 1958 | Keith M. Buckley | 1997 | ||
| Kenneth Robertson | 1959 | Scott Terry | 1998 | ||
| Gurley Hail | 1960 | Tom Guest | 1999 | ||
| Wayne Howle | 1961 | J.B. “Honest John” Rogers | 2000 | ||
| Tommy Worrell | 1962 | Ken Cotter | 2001 | ||
| J.D McCleskey | 1963 | Thomas Hooker Jr. | 2002 | ||
| J.R. “Bob” Russell | 1964 | Randy Lockhart | 2003 |
